Something That Really Hit My Like A Punch About SOTR Is How Suzanne Collins Decided To Write Haymitch's

Something that really hit my like a punch about SOTR is how Suzanne Collins decided to write Haymitch's relationship with the women in his life because (in a clear contrast with Snow) even in his times of doubt over them, even when he's talking about Drusilla (fuck her btw), he still has a level of respect Snow didn't show for any of the women in his life in TBOSAS.

He sees Maysilee and Louella as sisters and each of them have strengths he admires deeply — in contrast with Snow thinking of Tigris (his actual cousin) as someone whose appearance "invited abuse."

Even Lenore Dove's most worrisome characteristics come for Haymitch from a place of care and love for her, from a desire to keep her safe, not to control her. Haymitch loved Lenore Dove for who she was, regardless of her rebelliousness maybe causing trouble for him. I don't even have to mention the contrast to Snow, right?

Even Effie, whose alienation certainly annoyed him, is talked about in a way thay shows and extensive highlights her empathy beneath her propagandized opinions. Haymitch never disrespects Effie or thinks of her disrespectfully despite the fact that is hinted that she has some behaviors that annoyed him. Snow, however, thinks of his female classmates with a irritated tone that visibly undermines them and their good traits.

Even the contrast between Drusilla and Gaul. Right, Drusilla is not as powerful as Gaul when they're presented to the reader, and Haymitch and Snow come from very different places, but Drusilla is the closes thing Haymitch will get to a powerful ally from the Capitol. Yet, he rejects her (in a quieter way than Maysilee does but still does it) almost right away because of her obvious cruelty. It doesn't appeal to him is the slightest like it does to Snow.

Also, the contrast between how Snow and Haymitch see the sacrifices the women in their lives make with the former disgusted at Tigris and the later showing how much he loves his mom (also) because of all the sacrifices she made to keep him and Sid alive and well, even if it devastates him (like the fact that they don't have a cake in the birthdays in fairness to him not getting a cake or the loss of the shirt his mother had so carefully sewn together for him).

Suzanne Collins didn't just made her mission to say a big fuck you to people who were romanticizing Snow, she showed us what we all should expect from a man (again btw) and you gotta respect her for it.

Tags

More Posts from Swords-and-storms and Others

1 month ago

absolutely hilarious of Hollow Knight to answer the question "why are all the things I knock over back in perfect condition when I re-enter the room", a question that really doesn't need an answer because of how common it is in video games, with "there's a guild of bugs who are fixing things very very fast while you aren't looking"


Tags
1 month ago

i understand why the ‘grizzled loner who slowly melts & improves their outlook on life when forced to take care of a kid’ trope is a male exclusive role, bc the optics of a grizzled loner woman healing by becoming a mother are maybe not so good, but every time i think abt a hypothetical female version of that trope i black out instantly. could we maybe just do it one time and all agree to be cool about it


Tags
2 months ago
God, Please. Reveal Me The Truth.

god, please. reveal me the truth.

i need god to give me strength.

why does god seem so quiet to my petition.

prints + merch + c0mmission info pinned to profile :)


Tags
3 weeks ago

Just a reminder that we don’t know all the good things Katniss does/did for her community, because Katniss wouldn’t tell us unless it was relevant to what was going on.

In Catching fire, she doesn’t tell us that she’s being going around and bringing food to poor children in the seam until she needs to explain why she had a bag of food and why her mother wouldn’t find that odd.

Just A Reminder That We Don’t Know All The Good Things Katniss Does/did For Her Community, Because

In the first book, when she’s telling Peeta about the story of how she got Prims goat, she refuses to admit that this wasn’t a selfish move so she could get money out of that goat. (You could also argue that this is her refusing to be vulnerable in front of Peeta and all of Pamen though. I think it’s both, because she doesn’t even admit that she did this purely for her sister in her internal dialogue.)

Just A Reminder That We Don’t Know All The Good Things Katniss Does/did For Her Community, Because

And in Mockingjay, she never tells us that she’s the one that got Haymitch the goose eggs to help him heal after the games. All she says in the epilogue is that Haymitch raises geese when the liquor runs out. And we would never know otherwise if Haymitch didn’t mention that SHE was the one who got him the geese in sotr.

Just A Reminder That We Don’t Know All The Good Things Katniss Does/did For Her Community, Because
Just A Reminder That We Don’t Know All The Good Things Katniss Does/did For Her Community, Because

Tags
3 weeks ago
I Have Completed Another Crochet Monstrosity
I Have Completed Another Crochet Monstrosity
I Have Completed Another Crochet Monstrosity
I Have Completed Another Crochet Monstrosity
I Have Completed Another Crochet Monstrosity

I have completed another crochet monstrosity


Tags
2 weeks ago
Today's Warm Up: You'd Think, The Ocean Loving You, Would Make You Feel Small, A Minnow In Her Wake,
Today's Warm Up: You'd Think, The Ocean Loving You, Would Make You Feel Small, A Minnow In Her Wake,
Today's Warm Up: You'd Think, The Ocean Loving You, Would Make You Feel Small, A Minnow In Her Wake,

today's warm up: you'd think, the ocean loving you, would make you feel small, a minnow in her wake, but no. Out of the world, she loves you? That makes you big.


Tags
3 weeks ago

the thing i keep thinking about is how katniss, despite knowing the capitol is evil and despite seeing how they edited her games to tell a story, didn’t question haymitch’s much at all really when watching them. really drilling in the message that no one is immune to propaganda.


Tags
Loading...
End of content
No more pages to load
  • ouranophiliaa
    ouranophiliaa liked this · 3 days ago
  • buttcats
    buttcats liked this · 3 days ago
  • sunnyann
    sunnyann liked this · 4 days ago
  • m-i-c-art
    m-i-c-art liked this · 4 days ago
  • darlingtrees
    darlingtrees liked this · 4 days ago
  • vincentschild
    vincentschild liked this · 4 days ago
  • lilahfyre
    lilahfyre liked this · 4 days ago
  • bicokun
    bicokun liked this · 5 days ago
  • leylinelesbian
    leylinelesbian liked this · 5 days ago
  • glittering-under-the-glass
    glittering-under-the-glass liked this · 5 days ago
  • fake-geek-girl-616
    fake-geek-girl-616 liked this · 5 days ago
  • steelshard
    steelshard liked this · 5 days ago
  • screechthemighty
    screechthemighty reblogged this · 5 days ago
  • thegirlwholeapthroughtime
    thegirlwholeapthroughtime liked this · 5 days ago
  • aroacenecromancer
    aroacenecromancer liked this · 5 days ago
  • lupical-is-3racoons
    lupical-is-3racoons reblogged this · 5 days ago
  • lupical-is-3racoons
    lupical-is-3racoons liked this · 5 days ago
  • tim-aeus
    tim-aeus liked this · 5 days ago
  • asphodelweeps
    asphodelweeps reblogged this · 6 days ago
  • noicepersonwhocantart
    noicepersonwhocantart liked this · 6 days ago
  • abielaabitalescarraglimnt1
    abielaabitalescarraglimnt1 liked this · 6 days ago
  • mkwright-02
    mkwright-02 liked this · 6 days ago
  • ringofthenibelung-blog
    ringofthenibelung-blog reblogged this · 6 days ago
  • catastrophic29
    catastrophic29 liked this · 6 days ago
  • claired3lune
    claired3lune liked this · 1 week ago
  • mobsmadre
    mobsmadre liked this · 1 week ago
  • crypty
    crypty liked this · 1 week ago
  • lilachayze
    lilachayze liked this · 1 week ago
  • firealder2005
    firealder2005 liked this · 1 week ago
  • virtualflowerbatathlete
    virtualflowerbatathlete reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • virtualflowerbatathlete
    virtualflowerbatathlete liked this · 1 week ago
  • kangarooxvii
    kangarooxvii liked this · 1 week ago
  • blrghfarcillesaveme
    blrghfarcillesaveme liked this · 1 week ago
  • dah-queenie03
    dah-queenie03 liked this · 1 week ago
  • heroinicyfingers
    heroinicyfingers liked this · 1 week ago
  • gxrlypopologist
    gxrlypopologist liked this · 1 week ago
  • candicecrush10-blog
    candicecrush10-blog liked this · 1 week ago
  • angstyboiiiiii
    angstyboiiiiii reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • grtwdsmwhr
    grtwdsmwhr liked this · 1 week ago
  • lingering-sunrise
    lingering-sunrise liked this · 1 week ago
  • macaroonspluto
    macaroonspluto liked this · 1 week ago
  • vigilantegalleries
    vigilantegalleries liked this · 1 week ago
  • luttyloot
    luttyloot liked this · 1 week ago
  • moontides18
    moontides18 liked this · 1 week ago
  • apocalypticdreamscape
    apocalypticdreamscape liked this · 1 week ago
  • lgbtqforeverything
    lgbtqforeverything liked this · 1 week ago
  • j-u-s-tmyself
    j-u-s-tmyself reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • spin2196
    spin2196 liked this · 1 week ago
  • afuzzyknitsweaterboy
    afuzzyknitsweaterboy liked this · 1 week ago
  • loudygirlstuff
    loudygirlstuff reblogged this · 1 week ago
swords-and-storms - tragedy enjoyer
tragedy enjoyer

brb, running off to sea to seek my fortune! My crafts/art/miscellaneous hobbies are on my side blog, chlodobird-creations

168 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags