At&t - Blog Posts

My rant on the new iPhone Data Plans

I believe the term is "Indian Giver" - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_giver

That is in a nutshell how I see AT&T now.  Anyone who knows me has heard about my my rants on companies doing these kinds of things.  Recently, Pei Wei took away free soda with your carry out order.  Since they essentially made the soda worthless, customers assume the cost is built into the food (which it must be because the food isn't "cheap").

There are dozens of examples of this in the corporate and retail world and there are acceptable and unacceptable ways of doing this.  

Acceptable ways of changing the rules generally mean it's clear that you are getting a "deal".  For instance, Best Buy may do a promotion of Buy one, Get One (BOGO) free and that promotion may run for a week or 2 weeks or it may run for a year depending on the circumstances.  However, it's clear that you are operating under a promotion.  This is the case with Dish TV and DirecTV and Cable where they may "give" you promotional pricing for a year or they may "give" you HBO and Showtime for 3 months.  However, in all cases it's pretty clear you are getting a promotion.

Alternatively, if your cable company was giving you 200 channels and then said hey, we are going to now give you 20 channels but we will charge you $10 less, would that be "OK"?  I am going to guess no in 90% of the situations.

If, for instance, 95% of the people are in the under 200MB range, then why change the rules?  Does anyone honestly buy that this is in the consumer's best interest?  It's kind of sad if you really do. 

When someone gives you something and then takes it away, it's crap.  I use quite a bit more data for streaming Pandora and downloading movies for the kids via iTunes. God forbid if you find yourself on the road and your kids are screaming for Spongebob.

Guess what?  If you are on board with this plan, you're in trouble.  Gone are the days of surfing You Tube.  I find myself wondering what is the point of an iPhone when you are locked down on data?  Everyone knows that the iPhone SUCKS as a phone.  It's only advantage were the great apps that use data.

Why does the iPhone suck as a phone?

High-powered CDMA signals have raised the "noise floor" for GSM receivers, meaning there is less space within the available band to send a clean signal. This sometimes results in dropped calls in areas where there is a high concentration of CDMA technology. Conversely, high-powered GSM signals have been shown to cause overloading and jamming of CDMA receivers due to CDMA’s reliance upon broadcasting across its entire available band.

The result of this little cross-broadcasting joust has led some cities to pass ordinances limiting the space between cell towers or the height they can reach, giving one technology a distinct advantage over the other.

This is the case is most of the US where CDMA has the advantage.  

So, most would ask, why does my iPhone drop calls more than my Blackberry?  Well, the iPhone grabs more data on a tower in addition to the voice.  GSM towers hold connections for about 60 users each vs. CDMA holds about 300 users each.  So, what happens on the iPhone is that when you move from tower to tower, there is a higher likelihood that you will get squeezed out when you switch towers.  Certain areas of high usage make these drops happen more often.

So, now what we have is all these people putting up with crappy voice service because it's really a mobile mini computer with an always on data connection.  Taking that away is a really bad move and it ensures the continued adoption of Android en masse.  This is really sad for me personally because I feel like a strong offering from the iPhone will make all the options better, however this change will likely slow down advancements. 

Personally, I use quite a bit of data on my e-mail for opening and looking at docs while on the go.  I have actually been iPhone-less since I left my last job and I have been on my Droid 100%.  I "have" to go to an AT&T plan though and I have a stay atleast until June, but now I am thinking I might as well stay with Verizon and just suck it up.  I have a real problem with locking you down to 2GB and the fact that people are actually "buying in" to this is really shocking.

So, here is what I am seeing:

AT&T vs. Verizon:

Data - AT&T wins

Voice - Verizon wins

Apps:  (Taking Jailbreak/Root out of the equation) For all intents and purposes, it's a wash now for apps that you would regularly use, however:

Android gives you Google Voice, Chat, Maps, etc. and it's all free.  You have to pay for decent navigation on iPhone.  Both have Skype, however you have to pay for it on iPhone now.

AT&T just killed their only advantage over Verizon. 

I was so excited for the new iPhone (really, I was - I admit it) and I was actually going to buy it.  However, literally EVERYTHING costs more on iPhone and to be quite frank, the Android experience is pretty darn good.  I just wish AT&T would get a decent Android device.  

Stupid move ma bell.  Feel free to comment away :)