Your gateway to endless inspiration
I honestly have no concrete opinion right now, I like letting all versions exist simultaneously for the most part. But other than the usual son or Fingon or Orodreth, some others I've heard, ranked on outlandishness:
Lalwen's son
Glorfindel's kid, where Glorfindel is in turn Lalwen's son
Son of Caranthir (sometimes +Haleth)
A random kid Círdan found in the trash and said "yeah, I can work with this"
Finduilas in disguise
Actually Círdan's kid somehow, not Noldorin at all, they're running a con
Either Eluréd or Elurín in disguise. Or both depending on the day.
A Maia who got bored
Two dwarves in a trench coat
The ambiguity is so funny I love it.
PLEASE send me ur who-is-gil-galad theories i am losing my absolute mind rn
Elrond: Hostage or not, sometimes it's nice being held.
Gil-galad: Are you okay?
Made this a little while ago, I'll be doing more when I have the spoons for it lol.
The Silmarillion as Vines